Public Reel

A Star Is Born · Beat 72 · permalink

Private office

24:34–25:31 Registered 1937

Machine annotation by Qwen/Qwen3-VL-235B-A22B-Instruct, cut beats-0.2, prompt beats-0.2. Machine checks passed (partial). 4 quotes checked against the transcript; 2 names checked for a spoken or on-screen source; 2 of 4 visible events checked against a frame. Not human-reviewed. Observations and transcript may still be wrong.

Frame at 24:3624:36Frame at 24:5924:59Frame at 25:0825:08Frame at 25:2725:27

Play from 24:34 on the Internet Archive This passage on the film's page

Evidence and details

Starts here: pause in speech. Sequence 44 · shots 160–166. Observations cite a frame (frame:n) or a time (t:m:ss); frames are the sampled ones above.

Place
private_office (private office, interior) evidence: frame:1
People
  • Oliver (named at t:24:35): man in tuxedo, dark hair, medium build, standing on stairs visible, audible
  • man in tuxedo, receding hairline, mustache, medium build, standing on floor visible, audible
Seen happening
  • Two men in tuxedos stand in a dim room; one on stairs, one on floor. [frame:1]
  • The man on the floor gestures toward the man on stairs while speaking. [frame:2]
  • The man on stairs faces the other man, listening. [frame:3]
  • The man on the floor holds a yellow folder and turns away. [frame:4]
Also said
“I had a serious talk with Norman after that Hollywood boat occurrence.” 25:05 · “I'll turn on the radio and see if they've called out the National Guard yet.” 25:26
Seen
tuxedo [frame:1], stairs [frame:1], folder [frame:4], stone wall [frame:2], chair [frame:1]
Interpretation
Model opinion, not evidence: mood: tense but wry; themes: professional decline, Hollywood gossip, male camaraderie under stress; style notes: studio-lit, medium shots, formal attire, shadowy background

Two men in tuxedos converse in a dimly lit interior; one is addressed as Oliver and discusses directing, a man named Norman May, and a phone call about Mr. Mean. One man holds a folder and gestures while speaking.

“- Hello, Oliver. - Oh, hello, Cassie.” 24:35 · “A male nurse.” 24:43 automatic transcript, may be wrong

The record

No renewal found An automated finding, not a verdict. A renewal would have appeared in the Copyright Office's renewal registrations 27 to 29 years after the term began. Those volumes are loaded and our parse of them found no matching renewal. If that is right, a work published 1931–1963 that was not renewed entered the public domain at the end of its 28th year; the volumes are OCR of old print, and the method page reports how often the parse has been found to miss one. Evidence dossier. The finding concerns the US copyright record for the film; it is not clearance for any use, and this page's annotation is machine output.

Share

Paste the permalink anywhere that shows link previews and it carries the frame, the time and the finding. The card image can be saved and used with a credit.

Frame from A Star Is Born (1937) at 24:36 (passage 24:34–25:31); US record: No renewal found

Permalink
always the current cut
Permalink to this version
warns if the beats are recut later
Card image
https://publicreel.org/cards/moment/AStarIsBorn/b72.png
Figure for a newsletter or page
Cite